Perspective

Democracy as a Slogan, or Democracy as a Principle?

Semere T Habtemariam10 min read

About a decade ago, an Ethiopian opposition leader visited Dallas, Texas. At the time, I knew very little about him beyond the fact that he was an acquintance of my late friend, Ato Kidane Alemayehu, the founder of the Horn of Africa Peace and Development Center (hafrica.com), where I also serve as a board member. Today, that opposition leader serves as a minister in Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s government. Back then, however, he was among the most prominent figures in the Ethiopian opposition and a co-founder of Ginbot 7.

What made him particularly interesting to me was his relationship with the Eritrean regime and the fact that he had been sentenced to death in absentia by an Ethiopian court. He was not merely an occasional visitor to Eritrea. At one point, he resigned from a comfortable academic career in the United States, where he was a full professor of economics, relocated to Asmera, and devoted himself full-time to the struggle against the TPLF-dominated EPRDF government. Whatever one thought of his politics, that level of commitment was difficult not to admire. Here was a man willing to sacrifice a secure career in pursuit of political change. He came to my neck of the woods on a fundraising tour, using the opportunity to update supporters on the organization’s activities, objectives, and vision for the future.

Advertisement

Curious, I asked Ato Kidane a simple question: “What does he and his organization stand for?”

Without hesitation, he replied: “To bring democracy to Ethiopia.”

I smiled.

My reaction stemmed less from cynicism than from experience. I had heard those words far too many times before, only to see little come of them. The Ethiopian ruling party he sought to replace spoke the language of democracy. So did the Eritrean government hosting and supporting him. Across our region, democracy, human rights, liberty, justice, and the rule of law are among the most frequently invoked political phrases. Everyone claims them. Governments claim them. Opposition movements claim them. Rebels, activists, and politicians all speak the same language.

Donate

Donate to support awate.com

$

Donation Total: $100.00

Whether they truly believe it is, in some respects, beside the point. The fact that they feel compelled to invoke democracy is itself a tribute to its enduring appeal and moral authority. Too often, democracy serves as political rhetoric rather than a governing principle. In the Horn of Africa, one of the few exceptions has been Somaliland. Despite lacking international recognition, Somaliland has distinguished itself by building a comparatively democratic political system, holding competitive elections, facilitating peaceful transfers of power, and demonstrating a commitment to popular participation that remains rare in the region.

Ato Kidane noticed my reaction and asked why I smiled.

I replied, “That is what everyone says. But how seriously do you take him?”

Advertisement

“I take him very seriously,” he responded. “Seriously enough that I’m helping him.”

I then asked a question that had been on my mind.

“If he is genuinely committed to bringing democratic change to Ethiopia, isn’t allying himself with Isaias Afwerki the wrong way to go about it?”

Ato Kidane appreciated Isaias’s commitment to Ethiopian unity but abhorred the damage he was inflicting on Eritrea and its people. Likewise, he admired how Meles Zenawi had almost single-handedly transformed Ethiopia’s image on the international stage and yet deeply opposed the ethnic politics that underpinned his rule. He paused for a moment before responding.

Advertisement

“What other option does he have?”

I answered, “He could work with Eritreans who, like him, are struggling to bring democracy to Eritrea.”

The logic seemed straightforward. If democratic principles were truly the foundation of their respective political projects, solidarity among Ethiopian and Eritrean “democrats,” and indeed among democratic forces across the Horn of Africa, should have come naturally. They shared a common vision of political freedom, faced similar struggles against authoritarianism, and sought to build societies grounded in libral democracy. Though separated by borders, they were confronting many of the same challenges and, in many respects, fighting different fronts of the same battle.

“You have a point,” Ato Kidane replied. “Solidarity between the two should be natural.”

He then asked how such cooperation might begin.

I suggested something simple: open a channel of communication between the Ethiopian and Eritrean opposition movements. Nothing formal. Nothing dramatic. Just a dialogue between people supposedly committed to the same democratic ideals.

Ato Kidane welcomed the idea immediately. He promised to raise it and get back to me.

Encouraged by his response, I reached out to my friend, Tesfamichael Yohannes of the EPDP, for three reasons. First, he had long been skeptical of the Ethiopian government’s commitment to the Eritrean opposition, particularly democratic and nationalist forces. Second, he was a steadfast nationalist with an uncompromising commitment to Eritrean sovereignty. Third, his vision extended beyond regime change to the democratization of Eritrea itself. At the time, Tesfamichael served on the organization’s executive office and would later become its chairman.

Tefamichael Yohannes embraced the initiative enthusiastically, appreciating both its substance and its spirit. For a moment, it seemed possible to me that democratic forces in Eritrea and Ethiopia might forge a dialogue and build a relationship grounded in shared values, common aspirations, and a mutual commitment to democratic change.

That optimism lasted less than twenty-four hours.

The next day, Ato Kidane called me back, clearly disappointed.

The answer was no.

There was neither interest in building a relationship with the Eritrean opposition, non in communicating with them. The proposal was effectively dead upon arrival.

To be fair, the contradiction was not unique to the Ethiopian opposition. The Eritrean opposition was operating under similar circumstances. Many Eritrean opposition groups were based in Ethiopia and maintained working relationships with the Ethiopian government, which provided them with political space and support. They too faced the challenge of balancing principle with political dependency.

Yet that reality should have made cooperation even easier, not harder. Both sides understood the compromises imposed by exile politics. Both claimed to seek democracy. Both understood that authoritarianism in one country inevitably affects its neighbors.

I remember telling Ato Kidane that I understood the political calculations involved. Perhaps there was concern about offending an important patron. It is hard to bite the hand that feeds you. Perhaps there were strategic considerations that outweighed principle. As a compromise, I suggested that any communication need not even be public. Quiet discussions would have sufficed.

Even that generated no interest.

What struck me then, and what continues to strike me today, was the contradiction. Here was a movement claiming to champion democracy while showing little interest in engaging fellow “democrats” because doing so might inconvenience an authoritarian ally.

That experience forced me to confront an uncomfortable question: How many political actors truly believe in the principles they invoke?

Democracy is not merely a destination; it is also a method. It is reflected not only in the goals one pursues, but also in the alliances one builds, the compromises one accepts, and the standards one applies to friends and foes alike. If democratic values are truly universal, they cannot be invoked selectively or suspended for the sake of political convenience.

This is to underscore the well-established record of democracy as a system of governance that has delivered stability, accountability, and prosperity across much of the world. Nor is it to suggest that only committed “democrats” can bring about democratic change. History offers numerous examples of individuals and movements that helped open the door to democracy without being fully democratic themselves. The point, rather, is that the prospects for a successful and lasting democratic transition are greatest when democracy is embraced not only as the destination, but also as the method. Political movements are more likely to build durable democratic institutions when they practice the values they seek to establish, applying the same principles to allies and adversaries alike and resisting the temptation to subordinate them to short-term political expediency.

The episode also taught me something broader about politics in the Horn of Africa. Far too often, democracy becomes a slogan rather than a principle, a vehicle for acquiring power rather than a framework for exercising it. Political actors condemn authoritarianism when it excludes them and yet tolerate or even embrace it when it advances their immediate interests.

The same opposition-turned-minister, who once benefited from the patronage and support of Isaias Afwerki’s regime while leading an opposition movement against Ethiopia’s government, now stands among the defenders of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s maritime agenda. He has described Ethiopia’s “loss” of direct access to the sea as a “grave historical mistake” and argued that securing sea access is a national imperative, though he tempers that position by emphasizing peaceful negotiation and mutually beneficial arrangements with neighboring states.

The larger point remains that democratic credentials mean little if democratic principles are applied selectively. Democracy cannot be reduced to a means of attaining power while nationalism and raison d’état dictate what happens once power is secured. For democracy to take root, it must shape not only the destination political actors seek, but also the methods they employ and the standards they uphold along the way.

Today, I am reminded of that experience as I watch members of the Ethiopian opposition working alongside supporters of the Eritrean regime to advocate for peace and to avert another potentially devastating war between Eritrea and Ethiopia.

On principle, I welcome any initiative that genuinely speaks and acts in the language of peace. Preventing another conflict between our peoples is a noble and necessary objective. The Horn of Africa has suffered enough from war, displacement, and political violence. Only the reckless, the irresponsible, or the indifferent to human suffering would cheer for another needless war. Every conflict leaves behind shattered lives, broken families, stunted development, and wounds that can take generations to heal.

Yet I cannot help but think about the missed opportunity from years ago.

I would have preferred to see a broader and more inclusive coalition: a true solidarity of Ethiopians, Eritreans, and other citizens of the Horn of Africa who believe not only in peace, but also in democracy, human rights, accountability, and the rule of law. Such a coalition would transcend governments, ruling parties, and temporary political alliances. It would unite people around enduring principles rather than shifting interests.

That kind of regional solidarity has the potential to change the fate of the Horn of Africa. It could transform democracy from a slogan into a reality and peace from a temporary pause into a lasting condition.

The encouraging news is that it is not too late.

The challenges facing the peoples of Eritrea, Ethiopia, Sudan, Somalia, Djibouti, and the wider region are deeply interconnected. Authoritarianism, conflict, displacement, and economic stagnation do not respect national borders. Neither should the struggle for democracy and peace.

Democratic forces throughout the Horn of Africa must learn to cooperate, communicate, and support one another. A democratic breakthrough in one country strengthens the prospects for democracy in neighboring states. A victory for freedom in Eritrea would benefit Ethiopia. A democratic advance in Ethiopia would encourage reform elsewhere. Progress in Sudan or Somalia would reverberate throughout the region.

In that sense, the future of democracy in the Horn of Africa is not a national project but a regional one.

Any victory for democracy in one country is, ultimately, a victory for the entire region.

And that is a cause worthy of genuine solidarity.

 

To contact the author: weriz@yahoo.com

Meta Description:

A personal account of a missed opportunity for democratic solidarity between Eritrean and Ethiopian opposition movements, and a reflection on why genuine cooperation among democratic forces across the Horn of Africa remains essential for achieving lasting peace, freedom, and regional stability.

Tags: