All

Peace Through Sovereignty, Truth, and Mutual Respect

Semere T Habtemariam11 min read

Ten Principles for Lasting Peace Between Eritrea and Ethiopia

Both Eritrea and Ethiopia claim to enjoy close relations with Russia. When Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov offered to host and facilitate direct talks between Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and President Isaias Afwerki on the sidelines of the Third Russia-Africa Summit in Moscow, there appeared to be genuine cause for optimism. At a time of rising tensions and increasingly confrontational rhetoric, the prospect of dialogue offered a rare opening for de-escalation.

Advertisement

That optimism, however, proved short-lived. On the summit’s opening day, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed instead announced the accelerated delivery of twelve Russian-made Sukhoi Su-35 fighter jets, along with plans to acquire S-400 air defense systems from Moscow. The summit concluded without any visible mediation effort, fueling speculation about preconditions, diplomatic disagreements, or other obstacles that may have derailed meaningful engagement.

Yet the reasons behind the missed opportunity are ultimately less important than the deeper question it exposed: What foundations must be laid for a genuine and lasting peace between Eritrea and Ethiopia?

The themes explored in this column were inspired by discussions at the recent Tana Forum and by reports of an unconfirmed seven-point framework reportedly proposed by Ethiopia as a basis for dialogue. Yet the larger issue extends far beyond any initiative, mediator, or negotiating framework. The real challenge is not simply bringing the parties to the table but creating the conditions under which dialogue can produce a durable peace rather than serve as another brief interlude between recurring cycles of mistrust, tension, and confrontation.

My objective is neither to defend the position of one government nor to endorse the position of another. Rather, it is to examine the principles that should guide any future engagement between Eritrea and Ethiopia. More fundamentally, it seeks to address a prior question: should meaningful negotiations begin with preconditions, or should the first objective be creating an environment conducive to honest and constructive dialogue?

Donate

Donate to support awate.com

$

Donation Total: $100.00

Preventing another devastating conflict between the two peoples who have already paid a heavy price for war must remain the immediate priority. Yet avoiding war alone is not enough. The deeper challenge is addressing the sources of mistrust and insecurity that periodically revive tensions and threaten regional stability.

Peace requires institutions, mutual understanding, human connections, and habits of cooperation that, over time, make conflict unnecessary and eventually unthinkable. Eritrea and Ethiopia largely lack these foundations today. Yet every lasting peace starts somewhere. It starts with a decision that war has exhausted its usefulness and that coexistence is preferable to confrontation. From that simple but difficult commitment, the work of building a durable peace can begin.

Wars seldom begin because ordinary citizens desire them. More often, they arise when fears are amplified, grievances manipulated, and political differences are allowed to eclipse shared interests.

Advertisement

Today, both countries stand at a crossroads. One path leads toward increasing hostility, militarization, and uncertainty. The other points toward coexistence, cooperation, and stability. If genuine peace is to emerge, several principles must guide the journey. The following Ten Principles provide a framework for durable peace, one that safeguards the sovereignty, dignity, and interests of both nations while creating space for future cooperation.

  1. Unconditional Recognition of Sovereignty and Territorial Integrity

No lasting peace can exist if either side questions the legitimacy of the other’s sovereignty or seeks arrangements that undermine it.

Eritrea’s independence was secured through a long and costly struggle and affirmed through the internationally recognized referendum of 1993. Ethiopia likewise remains a sovereign state entitled to pursue its security and developmental aspirations.

This principle becomes particularly important amid continuing debate surrounding maritime access and the Red Sea. Ethiopia’s interest in securing reliable access to international trade routes reflects legitimate economic concerns. Eritreans, meanwhile, view sovereignty and territorial integrity as foundational principles rooted in decades of sacrifice.

Advertisement

These interests need not be incompatible. Lasting peace requires the recognition that economic cooperation and respect for sovereignty can coexist. Indeed, they must.

As President John F. Kennedy famously observed, “We cannot negotiate with people who say, ‘What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is negotiable.’” Any durable framework for peace must be built upon the understanding that the sovereignty of both states is equally worthy of respect.

  1. Mutual Commitment to Non-Interference

A durable peace requires more than the absence of direct conflict between states. It also requires a mutual commitment to refrain from actions that undermine the stability and security of neighboring countries.

For decades, governments across the Horn of Africa have, at various times, viewed armed opposition movements in neighboring states as instruments of leverage or pressure. Such policies may yield short-term tactical advantages, but they often produce long-term instability that harms everyone involved.

Eritrea and Ethiopia should therefore commit themselves to a clear principle of non-interference, including an agreement not to finance, arm, train, host, or otherwise support armed groups engaged in violent activities against the other state.

This principle should not be interpreted as opposition to political dissent. On the contrary, the most effective way to address internal grievances is through accommodation, reconciliation, political inclusion, and the recognition of legitimate democratic opposition. Peaceful political organization, criticism of government policy, and civic activism are essential elements of any healthy society.

Armed insurgencies, however, are a different matter. When neighboring states become sanctuaries for groups seeking to achieve political objectives through violence, mistrust deepens, security dilemmas intensify, and the prospects for peaceful relations diminish.

A lasting peace between Eritrea and Ethiopia requires confidence that neither government will seek influence through proxies, nor view destabilization across the border as an instrument of statecraft. The principle should be simple: political disagreements should be resolved through dialogue and political processes, not through the sponsorship of armed actors operating across international boundaries.

  1. Replacing Confrontation with Responsible Dialogue

Wars often begin long before armies move. They begin with narratives.

Language that appeals to historical grievances, territorial entitlement, or military solutions may generate short-term political support, but it rarely contributes to long-term stability.

Political leaders, journalists, intellectuals, activists, and members of the diaspora all have a role to play in lowering tensions and widening the space for diplomacy. Responsible rhetoric does not require abandoning national interests. It requires advancing those interests in ways that leave room for dialogue.

The language used today helps determine the choices available tomorrow.

  1. Transparency and Public Trust

One reason suspicion has often complicated Eritrean Ethiopian relations is the perception that major decisions affecting millions of people have been made without sufficient public transparency.

The optimism that accompanied the 2018 rapprochement demonstrated how deeply both people desire peace. It also demonstrated the importance of ensuring that peace initiatives are understood, debated, and broadly owned by the public.

Transparency does not weaken diplomacy. It strengthens legitimacy. Citizens who understand the direction of policy are more likely to support it and defend it.

  1. Historical Honesty Without Historical Imprisonment

Eritreans carry memories of annexation, armed struggle, wars, displacement, deportations, and sacrifice. Ethiopians carry memories of war, conflict, ethnic strife, political upheavals, and national traumas. More recently, the suffering associated with the Tigray war left profound scars that continue to shape perceptions throughout the region.

The purpose of acknowledging these experiences is not to determine whose suffering was greater. Such debates rarely advance reconciliation. Rather, it is to recognize that ordinary people, regardless of nationality or political affiliation, have borne the greatest costs of conflict.

The tragedies of the 1998-2000 border war and the more recent wars in northern Ethiopia should remind all parties that political disputes, when left unresolved, exact a terrible human price. Historical honesty should therefore encourage humility, empathy, and a renewed commitment to resolving differences peacefully.

  1. Transforming Borders into Bridges

Borders define states. They need not divide people.

For generations, communities on both sides shared commercial, cultural, religious, and familial ties. Conflict and militarization interrupted many of those connections.

The long-term objective should not simply be border management but border normalization. Legal trade, educational exchange, tourism, investment, and family reunification can coexist with respect for sovereignty.

A peaceful border is not merely one that is secure. It is one that allows neighboring communities to prosper.

  1. Economic Cooperation Based on Mutual Benefit

Geography has made Eritrea and Ethiopia neighbors. Economics can make them partners.

Ethiopia’s vast market, growing population, and economic potential complement Eritrea’s strategic location along one of the world’s most important maritime corridors. Properly structured cooperation can create opportunities that benefit both societies without compromising the independence of either.

Throughout history, nations connected by trade, investment, and economic interdependence have often discovered that cooperation is more profitable than confrontation. Shared prosperity may not erase political disagreements, but it can create compelling incentives to manage them peacefully. Eritrea and Ethiopia should therefore make fuller use of continental, regional, and bilateral platforms to address their differences, build confidence, and prevent disputes from hardening into crises.

  1. Peace Must Be Rooted in Society

Governments can open the door to peace, but only societies can keep it open.

One of the central shortcomings of previous rapprochements was their reliance on political leaders instead of broad societal participation. The practice of placing all eggs in one basket must end. Lasting peace requires the active engagement of religious leaders, educators, artists, entrepreneurs, civil society organizations, youth movements, and diaspora communities.

History has repeatedly shown that relationships between people are often more enduring than relationships between governments. The wider the constituency invested in peace, the stronger its foundations and the greater its ability to withstand changes in leadership, political crises, and moments of tension.

  1. Development as a Strategic Priority

The greatest challenges facing both Eritrea and Ethiopia are developmental rather than military.

Poverty, unemployment, food insecurity, migration, environmental pressures, and infrastructure deficits continue to affect millions of citizens throughout the region. These challenges demand resources, innovation, and cooperation.

Every investment in education, healthcare, infrastructure, and economic opportunity contributes more to long-term security than another cycle of confrontation. The future of the region will be determined not by military strength alone, but by the ability of its people to build prosperous and resilient societies.

  1. Regional Stability as a Shared Interest

Instability in one country inevitably affects the other through migration, trade disruptions, humanitarian pressures, and regional insecurity. Conversely, stability in one strengthens stability in the other.

This reality explains why African institutions and regional actors consistently emphasize negotiation and dialogue. Peace between Eritrea and Ethiopia is no longer merely a bilateral concern. It is central to the future stability and prosperity of the Horn of Africa.

Yet institutions and agreements alone cannot guarantee peace. Peace depends upon leadership.

History’s most effective leaders are not those who mobilize people through fear, but those who inspire them through purpose. They recognize that statesmanship consists not merely of defending national interests but of enlarging the possibilities available to future generations.

As the United States emerged from its Civil War, Abraham Lincoln urged his countrymen to proceed “with malice toward none; with charity for all.” Earlier, he had appealed to “the better angels of our nature.” His words endure because they recognized a timeless truth: reconciliation is not weakness. It is often the highest expression of political courage. For both Eritrea and Ethiopia, no external policy can compensate for deep internal fractures. People reconciled with one another are less susceptible to external manipulation, more resilient in the face of foreign pressure, and better equipped to defend their sovereignty. Domestic reconciliation and national unity are therefore not acts of charity but acts of strategic wisdom. They are the surest way to reduce vulnerabilities, strengthen national resilience, and secure durable peace.

That lesson remains relevant today. Both Eritrea and Ethiopia would benefit from leaders capable of appealing to the highest aspirations of their peoples rather than their deepest fears, leaders willing to demonstrate that patriotism and peace are not opposing values but complementary ones.

Conclusion

The Horn of Africa has produced peoples of extraordinary resilience, determination, and endurance. The challenge now is to transform those qualities into a foundation for lasting peace.

The central question facing Eritreans and Ethiopians is not who owns yesterday. History, with all its triumphs and tragedies, has already left its mark. The more important question is who will inherit tomorrow.

A peaceful future will not emerge from forgetting the past, nor from endlessly relitigating it. It will emerge from the wisdom to learn from it.

If Eritreans and Ethiopians can balance legitimate national interests with a commitment to peaceful coexistence, they have an opportunity to transform one of Africa’s most difficult relationships into a model of pragmatic cooperation, mutual respect, and regional leadership.

The future remains unwritten. The choice, and the responsibility, belong to this generation.

To Contact the author: weriz@yahoo.com