Negarit

Silence on Reconciliation (Sqtan Erqn)

Saleh G. Johar6 min read

Why would the PFDJ government Ignore the Importance of Reconciliation? Why would anyone, particularly in a divided nation, reject the idea of reconciliation? Is that rejection universal or particular? Why do I consider reconciliation a precondition for having a healthy, prosperous nation? Are make-believe folklore and politicized catchphrases an alternative to real reconciliation? Can a nation that doesn’t have freedom of expression and press achieve meaningful dialogue to achieve reconciliation?

Today’s Negarit 398 will address these issues.

Advertisement

Let me start with two of the most disappointing remarks I heard at meetings, from the mouths of two senior PFDJ officials. I will begin with Yousif Saiq’s mocking reaction to my question to Isaias Afwerki at the Beyan Palace in Kuwait.

As usual, Isaias gave an opening speech, mainly admiring the Eritrean struggle against the enemy. Then came the questions from the attendees. I was the first or second person to ask, and I will paraphrase my question: Why is it that we, as a people, have not reconciled as a nation? Or, at the very least, why has your ruling party not called for reconciliation or allowed other organizations to participate in the government?

The late Ambassador Mohammed Ismail Omer was sitting to Isaias’ left. He looked at me with contempt and disdain, as if by asking I had committed a serious mistake. He leaned towards Isaias and whispered something to him. I was sitting close enough to read his lips, and his gestures made it clearer. With a smirk, Isaias nodded his head and told Mohammed Omer, “Dehan gdefo.” (No problem, let him be.)

Isaias gave what seemed to be a wise answer but then spoiled it: “We do not discriminate between our combatants and the others [meaning other struggle era combatants]. In fact, we give the others priority in providing housing, jobs, and other forms of care, even at the expense of our own members.”

Keep awate.com and Negarit Alive

$2,465 raised of $12,000 goal · 22 donations

It was my turn to feel disdainful; the audience was allowed only one question, with no follow-up. I was disappointed. Does that mean there are combatants who deserve priority? And if veterans received benefits they are entitled to, should that be seen as a favor?

It confirmed to me that Isaias and his organization would not abandon their hegemonic attitude or their sense of superiority. That didn’t bode well, and it hasn’t.

Yusuf Saiq

Advertisement

Later, after the meeting, I saw Yousif Saiq walking out of the hall. He approached me, not scornfully but mockingly: “Saleh, Hezib ktide Hazeka?” (Saleh, do you want to form a party?!). He was covering his mouth, apparently finding my question to Isaias embarrassing or unacceptable. I smiled and walked away. I didn’t want to make a scene in the presence of so many people, in a hall within the Kuwaiti Amir’s Palace complex. I never met Yousif again after that.

Abdella Jabir

Abdalla Jabir was the organizational affairs chief until he was arrested in 2013. He was accused of being one of the leaders of the Forto mutiny, led by Colonel Said Ali Hijay, widely known as Wedi-Hijay. I wish Abdalla Jabir freedom, if he is still alive.

It was ironic that he was arrested by the very PFDJ organization he had served loyally as head of its organizational affairs department.

Advertisement

In 1997, in Kuwait, I attended a public meeting conducted by him. I had two burning issues at the time.

The first was that the PFDJ had erased all the traditional regional names and replaced them with lazy names based on the compass directions of their locations in Eritrea. Sahel, Semhar, Dankalia and Sahel were replaced by Southern Red Sea and Northern Red Sea. Seraye, Akele Guzay, and Hamassen were incorporated into a new region called South. Senhit, parts of Barka, parts of Hamassen, and Sahel were combined into a new region called Anseba. The boundaries of Barka and Gash were slightly redrawn. The capital city was separated from Hamassen and made a region of its own.

All the roads lead to the capital city

The Italians had designed Eritrea’s transportation arteries, and other infrastructure, based on the traditional regional boundaries. The new boundaries drawn by the PFDJ forced many localities to fall under administrations located in other cities.

I personally met elderly, unhappy woman who disapproved of the new regional boundaries and explained: “Our courts and administrative offices were in Asmara. I would take the bus from my village in Adi Neamin to Asmara, do what I needed to do, and return home to my village by late afternoon.

“After the regions were redrawn, I had to travel to Asmara to reach Keren, the capital of my new region. But by the time I arrived, it would be too late to accomplish much. I would have to stay overnight. In Keren. The following day after finishing my work there following day, I would have to travel back to Asmara, and from there continue to my village.”

A city dweller or someone who is well-to-do might not feel the impact, but ordinary villagers really suffer.

These are the less serious inconveniences. There are other issues tied to land, as well as related legal and emotional concerns.

At the meeting in Kuwait that I mentioned, I asked Mohamed Omer Mahmoud the about the naming of the regional and redrawing regional boundaries. His reply was dishonest. He said that these were merely administrative boundaries and were not meant to replace the traditional names. We now know that it was intended to be a permanent social re-engineering exercise, or somewhat equivalent of what is known as gerrymandering in the USA though the idea of voting has now dawned on the PFDJ.

But I also had another question for Abdalla Jabir, a question that discomforts all PFDJ leaders and followers alike:

Why is national reconciliation still not being treated with the urgency it deserves?

It was as if I had pinched him on the face. He responded: “Who do you want us to reconcile with, the nefer-neferen?” [Arabic demeaning remark, “one or two people,”]

Nefer-neferen is an Arabic expression meant to diminish the number of people calling for reconciliation. It literally means ‘one or two elements! A deliberate belittling remark discounting large social and political groups into something negligible!

The sad thing is that this indoctrination has become deeply rooted in the minds of most PFDJ followers, particularly the youth. They commonly attack and mock anyone who raises the issue of reconciliation.